Introduction | About the project | Researchers | Events | Conference 2027 | Reports | Photogallery | Texts | Library
Call for papers
I. Heading and Identifying Information
Conference title and subtitle:
Cosmopolitanism and Tianxia: Toward the Shared Grounds of Mutually Beneficial and Respectful Understanding in Global Political Thought
Organizing and co-sponsoring institutions:
Institute of Philosophy, Slovak Academy of Sciences
Research Center for Humanities and Social Sciences, Academia Sinica
Venue:
SAS Congress Center, Zámocká street 18, 919 04 Smolenice, Slovakia
https://smolenickyzamok.sav.sk/en
Dates: June 23 – 26, 2027
Language: English
Format: in person
II. Statement of Theme (Rationale / guiding problematic)
“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.” Technological progress and material prosperity now coincide with the ongoing climate change, war, mass migration, the regulation of artificial intelligence, and a widening gap between the Global North and the Global South. What this situation demands is action across borders, and with it a mode of thinking that, as Zhao Tingyang urges, begins from the world itself: a “thinking that emerges from the world.” What could ground such thinking, how far it reaches, and in what institutions it might take shape all remain open. This conference takes up three questions on which current debate divides.
The first concerns the ground and the form of care for others that extends beyond one’s own community. Cosmopolitanism of the Stoic-Kantian type grounds it in a normative but abstract idea of the human being and casts it as duty; Kwame Anthony Appiah objects that such care holds only where it is culturally rooted. The Chinese tradition conducts a related dispute in its own idiom: Mohism opposes graded care with care that makes no distinctions (jian’ai 兼愛), while Confucianism defends the extension of what is close at hand to what is distant (tui’en 推恩). Does that extension reach the stranger, or is gradation a concession to human finitude? And does the line between duty and love fall between the two traditions, or run across both?
The second concerns the normative standing of tianxia. Is it a universal concept of order that makes a distinctive contribution to global political thought, or a Großraum in Carl Schmitt’s sense with Chinese characteristics, a hegemony presenting itself as an order? By what criteria should that judgment be made — and would cosmopolitanism itself survive them, given the long-standing charge that it too dresses a particular provenance in universal terms? The question arises in the plural as well, since neither “cosmopolitanism” nor “tianxia” names a single doctrine.
The third concerns institutional form. Given an interconnected world, is the state now to be justified only instrumentally, or does it remain a form of political association that has value in itself? Can the European Union be understood as an institutional realisation of cosmopolitan claims, and what would be the corresponding modern shape of tianxia? Does a normativity oriented to care require different institutions from one oriented to duty?
Across all three lies a question of method: how can we understand one another on each other’s own terms without lapsing into radical cultural relativism, and without silently reading one tradition in the categories of the other? The conference invites contributions that address these questions historically, in normative theory, or in comparative perspective.
III. Suggested Topics
Contributions are invited on the following themes; the list is not exhaustive, and proposals that cut across two or more of them are especially welcome.
1. The Grounds and Modes of Care Beyond One’s Own Community
- Do universalist claims operate in the grammar of duty — what we owe to every human being — or in that of love and attachment? Are these two distinct modes in which normativity binds, and what is lost when one is translated into the other?
- The Mohist–Confucian dispute revisited: does the extension of care from those near at hand ever reach the stranger? Is gradation a concession to human finitude, or a normative principle in its own right? And is a care that makes no distinctions too demanding to be required of anyone — an objection the Mohists themselves anticipated, and one that returns in contemporary debates over the demandingness of cosmopolitan obligation?
- The possibility and limits of rooted cosmopolitanism: can we hold both that we are bound to a particular culture, and therefore tied more closely to those who share it, and that we are capable of caring for the lives and sufferings of strangers? Can cosmopolitanism survive in a fully abstract form, or does it work only within a bounded cultural zone?
- Varieties of rooted cosmopolitanism: African, Confucian, and others.
2. The Normative Standing of Tianxia
- Is tianxia a universal concept of order, or a Großraum in Carl Schmitt’s sense with Chinese characteristics? What would count as evidence for either reading?
- The historical origins and development of both concepts in the history of political thought, and what bearing that history has on their present use.
- “Cosmopolitanism” and “tianxia” each name a family of positions rather than a single doctrine. Do the variants share a normative core, or only a name? And how far does an objection raised against one version carry over to the rest?
- Are the two philosophically complementary, or do they differ fundamentally?
3. Institutional Form
- What institutional form is suited to realising perpetual peace and to addressing global problems? (An old question that remains unanswered.)
- Does the state exist for instrumental reasons only, or does it remain a form of political association that has value in itself?
- If the European Union can be read as one institutional realisation of cosmopolitan claims, what would be the corresponding modern institution for tianxia?
- Does a normativity grounded in care require different institutions from one grounded in duty?
4. Questions of Method
- How can we understand one another on each other’s own terms without lapsing into radical cultural relativism?
- Is it possible to advance a theory that raises a universal claim and remains particularly rooted? What would such a theory look like?
- Does comparison presuppose a shared frame, and if so, whose? Is “cosmopolitanism” itself the right frame in which to pose the question, or does adopting it already cast one tradition as the case study?
IV. Keynote Speakers
Stephen C. Angle (Wesleyan University)
Leigh Jenco (London School of Economics and Political Science)
Jana Rošker (University of Ljubljana)
Tong Shijun (East China Normal University/New York University Shanghai)
Roy Tseng (Academia Sinica)
V. Important Dates and Information
Abstract deadline: January 31, 2027
Notification of acceptance: February 28, 2027
Fees: no fees
VI. Contact person
Ľubomír Dunaj (Institute of Philosophy, Slovak Academy of Sciences) lubomir.dunaj@savba.sk
Introduction | About the project | Researchers | Events | Conference 2027 | Reports | Photogallery | Texts | Library